What the law actually says
You can decline a holiday request, and you can require staff to take leave at certain times, as long as you follow the rules on notice and don't discriminate. The law gives you the right to say no to a specific date, provided you give the correct notice and treat people consistently.
What the law doesn't do is tell you who wins when two people clash. That is a management decision, and it is where fairness, or the lack of it, gets noticed.
Have a clear policy, before the clash
The single best way to avoid holiday rows is to decide the rules in advance, in writing, and apply them every time. Set out how much notice you need, how many people can be off at once, and how you decide when requests clash.
When the rule is known and consistent, a no feels like the policy, not favouritism. When there is no rule, every decision looks personal.
If you don't have a written holiday policy, put one in place now, before the next clash, not during it.
Fair ways to decide a clash
Common, defensible approaches include first come, first served by date of request; rotating priority, so the person who missed out last time gets it this time; or business need, where the role that is harder to cover takes priority. Any of these is fine, as long as you pick one, write it down, and stick to it.
What matters isn't which method you choose, it is that it is consistent and you can explain it.
What not to do
Don't decide case by case with no logic, that is how accusations of favouritism start. Don't always let the loudest or most senior person win. And be careful that your approach doesn't, even accidentally, disadvantage particular groups, for example parents around school holidays, which can raise a discrimination risk.
Consistency is both your protection and your peace-keeper.
“Brilliant in advising me on a recent delicate HR matter. Her professionalism and knowledge shone through, and she was extremely quick and responsive throughout.”
Key takeaways
- You can say no to a date, if you give notice and treat people consistently.
- Decide the rules in writing before the clash, not during it.
- Pick one fair method for clashes and apply it every time.
- Avoid favouritism, and watch for unintended discrimination.
- A holiday clash turning into something bigger? Take the free Situation Check.
Not ready to book? Just tell me what's going on and I'll come back to you. No obligation.
